Medulloblastoma in
adults: treatment results and prognostic factors
Abacioglu U, International Journal of
Radiation Oncology*Biology*Physics 01 November 2002 (Vol.
54, Issue 3, Pages 855-860)
To
investigate the treatment outcome and prognostic factors of
adult medulloblastoma
patients who received postoperative craniospinal irradiation (RT).
Between 1983 and 2000,
30 adult patients (17 men and 13 women, age ≥16 years,
median 27, range 16–45) underwent postoperative RT. The median
duration of symptoms was 2 months (range 1–9).
The tumor location was
lateral in 16 (53%). A desmoplastic variant was seen in 12
(40%). Tumor resection was complete in 20 (67%) and incomplete
in 10 (33%). All patients received craniospinal RT. The
median dose to the whole
brain was 40 Gy (range 36–51), to the posterior fossa 54 Gy
(range 49–56), and to the spinal axis 36 Gy (range
24–40). The median interval between surgery and the start of RT
was 31 days (range 12–69), and the median duration of RT was 45
days (range 34–89). Ten patients (33%) received adjuvant
chemotherapy. The median follow-up was 51 months (range 5–215).
The
5- and 8-year overall
survival and disease-free survival rates were 65% and 51% and
63% and 50%, respectively. Twelve patients (40%)
developed relapse, with a median follow-up of 51 months. The
posterior fossa was the most common site of relapse (6
patients). The median time to relapse was 26 months (range
4–78). Fifty percent of the relapses occurred after 2 years, 17%
after 5 years. In univariate analysis, M stage and the interval
between surgery and the start of RT were significant prognostic
factors for disease-free survival. At 5 years, 70% of M0
patients were estimated to be disease-free, but none of the 3 M3
patients reached 5 years without recurrence (p
= 0.0002). The 5-year disease-free survival rate for the
patients whose interval between surgery and the start of RT was
<3 weeks, between 3 and 6 weeks, and >6 weeks was 0%, 85%, and
75%, respectively (p =
0.002). The 5-year posterior fossa control rate for patients who
received ≥54 Gy or <54 Gy to the posterior fossa was 91% and
33%, respectively (p =
0.05).
Conclusion: The
survival results for medulloblastomas in adults compare
favorably with those in children. However, late relapses,
lateral tumor location, and desmoplastic histologic features are
more frequent in adults. Spinal seeding at presentation is a
poor prognostic factor for disease-free survival.
A minimal dose of 54 Gy
to the posterior fossa is essential for adequate tumor control.
The interval between surgery and the start of RT, which was
found to be a significant prognostic factor, is an interesting
issue that requires further study.
|
Discussion |
|
|
The
adult presentation of
medulloblastoma
is an infrequent disease entity that shows both
similarities and discrepancies with its pediatric
counterpart. Adult
medulloblastoma differs mainly in the incidence
of more laterally located tumors and more desmoplastic
histologic findings compared with pediatric tumors. In
the current study, a lateral location was observed in
53% and desmoplastic histologic features in 40% of the
patients. In previous adult
medulloblastoma
series, the incidence of a lateral location was reported
to be 29–71% and that of desmoplastic histologic
features 25–50%. Park reported an incidence of 7%
lateral tumors and 18% desmoplastic variant in 144
children with
medulloblastoma.
The
5-year survival rate in this study compares favorably
with both pediatric and adult
medulloblastoma
series. In well-documented retrospective adult
medulloblastoma
series reporting results of 13–147 patients, the 5-year
overall survival rate ranged between 40% and 84% and the
disease-free survival rate between 32% and 63%. In the
current study, the disease-free survival rate was 63% at
5 years, but had decreased to 50% by 8 years. One-half
of the recurrences were after 2 years, contrary to
pediatric patients whose tumors recur mostly in the
first 2 years.
Spinal seeding at presentation, although not very
common, is one of the most important prognostic factors
for recurrence. In the current study, only 3 patients
had evidence of spinal metastases at diagnosis, and all
had recurrence despite adequate postoperative treatment.
This result is consistent with other adult
medulloblastoma
series.
The
RT dose to the posterior fossa appeared to be a
significant prognostic factor for posterior fossa
control in the current study, similar to other studies
in both pediatric and adult populations. A radiation
dose of 54 Gy is suggested as the threshold dose for
postoperative effectiveness. Higher radiation doses ≤72
Gy, fractionated, twice daily have not revealed superior
control.
Usually, the aim is to keep the interval between surgery
and RT as short as possible, taking into account
operative scar tissue healing in all postoperative
oncologic situations. The studies investigating this
factor have not been able to show a detrimental effect
of a delay in treatment results for
medulloblastoma.
In a study from the University of Florida, prolongation
of the overall RT treatment time adversely affected the
treatment results, but the interval between surgery and
the start of RT had no effect on the treatment results
for the pediatric
medulloblastoma patients. In the study by Jenkin
from Saudi Arabia in which 16% of 173 patients were >14
years old, no significant differences in outcome were
found when the variables of the time from the first
resection to the first day of RT (<25 vs. ≥25 days) and
the duration of any interruption of RT in excess of 7
days were evaluated. In our study, patients with a
shorter interval between surgery and RT (≤3 weeks) were
found to have a worse prognosis compared with patients
with medium and longer intervals (3–6 and ≥6 weeks). It
is difficult to draw a definitive conclusion with these
results, because no biologic explanation was found and
the patient numbers were small. It may be only a
coincidence, but needs further investigation.
One-third of our patients received adjuvant
chemotherapy. Although no definite scheme or criteria
were present for this group, we were not able to show
any benefit by adding chemotherapy. Additionally, it is
difficult to draw any conclusions from previous reports
to show any advantage. The most prominent useful effect
of adjuvant chemotherapy was shown in the study from the
Royal Marsden Hospital. Patients treated with
megavoltage RT and chemotherapy had a 5-year survival
rate of 76% compared with 37% after RT alone. However,
as they stated, other factors were present that could
have contributed to the better survival such as a higher
posterior fossa dose, earlier spinal RT, and more total
or subtotal resection in the patients who received
chemotherapy. |
|
Conclusion |
|
|
Surgery and postoperative craniospinal RT are the
mainstay treatments for adult
medulloblastoma
patients. Long-term follow-up is necessary, because late
recurrences are not rare. Spinal seeding at presentation
is a poor prognostic factor for recurrence. The
posterior fossa radiation dose must be kept at a minimum
of 54 Gy for adequate control. The interval between
surgery and the start of RT is an interesting issue that
requires further study. The role of adjuvant
chemotherapy needs further investigation in prospective
multi-institutional studies. |